cow kisses cat

How a Pile Up of Dead Cows Led to the Discovery of What’s In Pet Food. And It’s Much Worse Than You Think.

“Fresno County declares emergency as cow carcasses pile up. Plant to temporarily close” and “Merced County declares an emergency, as cattle carcasses pile up from rendering plant issue.”

It’s just the sort of headlines I dread. Even though I know what the rendering industry does – which is recycling dead livestock, animal by-products, expired meat and used cooking oil – I began to wonder with a morbid fascination what does a cow looks like after it’s lain outside after – say – a week or two. I mean really look like. Up close.

TEN DAYS

It started when a boiler started leaking at a livestock rendering plant in Fresno County, causing it to work inefficiently. The rendering plant, Baker Commodities, which covers the Southwest Region of the United States, and the only one of its size in the Central San Joaquin Valley, was forced to shut down Feb 21 while they fixed their equipment. And that’s when the carcasses began piling up, and the company was forced to stop picking up dead cows, bulls, and horses. By the time the rendering plant resumed operations on March 6, animals had been out there for ten days.

PUTREFACTION

Typically, the rendering process involves first removing the animals’ hides at Baker Commodities Hanford facility and then hauling the rest of the carcasses to its Kerman facility, where the boiler broke down, to complete the rendering process. But once an animal has decayed past a certain point – after ten days, for example – removing the skins becomes problematic, and the entire body must be rendered whole. While in practice, horses should be separated from the other animals, particularly as they may have been euthanized with pentobarbital when the horses decay past the point of being a solid mass, separating them from other animals becomes impossible.

BACKLOG

Then Darling Ingredients, Inc., the only other livestock renderer in Fresno County, reported mechanical failures forcing the company to stop its rendering operation on Feb 28. When the only two area livestock rendering facilities suffering malfunctions in the San Joaquin Valley, livestock owners who depend upon such plants to dispose of deceased animals were in a panic. While equipment issues at both plants impacted the area, it was the Darling Ingredients plant malfunction that triggered the local emergency. Darling Ingredient’s plant in Fresno is typically capable of process around 850,000 pounds of bones, fat, and other refuse a day, even though Darling’s facility was back up and running a few days later, the backlog of animal carcasses persists. If the accumulated carcasses are not mitigated by the local emergency’s March 31 deadline, it may be extended. However, the backlog is expected to be cleared within a few weeks.

DEADSTOCK

Fortunately, the local emergency allowed county landfills to temporarily receive dead livestock. Some landfills have a license to receive livestock mortalities regularly or when an emergency proclamation is made. The situation, however, shows how fragile the system is for dairymen who are legally unable to bury or burn deceased livestock. This is why farmers are utterly dependent on renderers who perform an invaluable service to the community. And it’s not just farmers and the meat and poultry industry who rely on renderers, it’s supermarket chains who dispose of expired grocery store meat, and food chains who need to dispose of used cooking oil.

MARSHMALLOWS

Without renderers – and it’s hard to imagine the picture – the U.S. would be overwhelmed with an unimaginable volume of animal mortalities and animal by-products. There is no question renderers provide an essential service: disposing of millions of pounds of dead animals every day. No one can question the necessity of such an industry, in fact, most people use rendered products every day, they just don’t realize it, because it is used in so many things: cosmetics, candles, detergents, gelatin, lard, soaps, even marshmallows. And of course pet food and animal feed.

PET FOOD

Not many consumers are aware that most pet foods on the market contain rendered ingredients, including pet food ingredients manufactured by Darling Ingredients, and Baker Commodities’ protein meal and animal fats. It’s pretty hard to walk down the aisle of a grocery store and avoid buying a pet food product that wasn’t made using some rendered product in it. After all, the pet food industry is the largest user of rendered fats and proteins.

Perhaps it was just bad luck or a bad two weeks for farmers, maybe dealing with dead animals is an inconvenience that farmers and renderers have to deal with daily as part of doing business. But for consumers who buy pet food that contains rendered material, the story illustrates how consumers might want to be aware of what happens on the days when everything doesn’t go as planned at the local rendering plant. Consumers should be aware that it is not just possible that bad things happen, but that they do.

FILTHY, PUTRID, OR DECOMPOSED

The National Renderers Association’s guidance for rendering plants certifying in the Rendering Code of Practice and Animal Feed Industry Association’s FSC36 Safe Feed/Safe Food program outline how processing filthy, putrid, and decomposing animals is an acceptable means of turning the material into useful feed ingredients for animals:

Decomposition of animal tissues begins the moment slaughter takes place, and some time is needed to get these materials into the rendering process. Decomposition is not always a negative for product quality and food safety. The rendering process effectively “re-sets the clock” by processing raw materials including offal, outdated meat, and fallen animals that may be deemed filthy, putrid, or decomposed substances with respect to human food into safe, wholesome, and useful feed ingredients for animals.

Which, oddly, is in direct conflict with the Federal Food Drug and Cosmetic Act, 21 U.S. Code § 342 Adulterated food that states a food shall be deemed to be adulterated (poisonous, insanitary, etc.):

“…if it consists in whole or in part of any filthy, putrid, or decomposed substance, or if it is otherwise unfit for food; or if it has been prepared, packed, or held under insanitary conditions whereby it may have become contaminated with filth, or whereby it may have been rendered injurious to health; or if it is, in whole or in part, the product of a diseased animal or of an animal which has died otherwise than by slaughter.”

THE STAGES OF DECOMPOSITION
When searching for a good illustration of the process of decomposition – of what a ten-day-old cow might look like, for example – I came across the Australian Museum’s Department of Natural Science’s study of the stages of decomposition carried out on a piglet. The website explains:

Decomposition of a corpse is a continual process that can take from weeks to years, depending on the environment. Below we have divided the process into stages, which are characterised by particular physical conditions of the corpse and the presence of particular animals.
To illustrate the process of decomposition, we use the piglet as the model corpse. Piglets are used because a 40 kg pig resembles a human body in its fat distribution, cover of hair and ability to attract insects. These factors make pigs the next best things to humans when it comes to understanding the process of decay of the human body. The pigs in this website are newborn piglets (weighing about 1.5 kg) that have been accidentally crushed by their mothers – a key cause of death of piglets. Their bodies have been donated to science.

Please note – this set of images contain strong graphic references.


STAGES OF DECOMPOSITION | Stage 1: Live Animal

newborn piglets (weighing about 1.5 kg)

Newborn piglets (weighing about 1.5 kg)

STAGES OF DECOMPOSITION | Stage 2: Initial decay – 0 to 3 days after death

Decomposition of pig, Stage 2: Initial decay State of decay Although the body shortly after death appears fresh from the outside, the bacteria that before death were feeding on the contents of the intestine begin to digest the intestine itself. They eventually break out of the intestine and start digesting the surrounding internal organs. The body's own digestive enzymes (normally in the intestine) also spread through the body, contributing to its decomposition. On an even smaller scale, enzymes inside individual cells are released when the cell dies. These enzymes break down the cell and its connections with other cells. Insect activity From the moment of death flies are attracted to bodies. Without the normal defences of a living animal, blowflies and house flies are able to lay eggs around wounds and natural body openings (mouth, nose, eyes, anus, genitalia). These eggs hatch and move into the body, often within 24 hours. The life cycle of a fly from egg to maggot to fly takes from two to three weeks. It can take considerably longer at low temperatures. Image: R Major © Australian Museum

Stage 2: Initial decay

stage one of decay dead pig fly

Stage 2: Initial decay – 0 to 3 days after death; Fly attracted to the dead pig.

Fly eggs on dead pig Image: R. Major © Australian Museum

Stage 2: Initial decay – 0 to 3 days after death; Fly eggs on dead pig

Fly larvae - Maggots, First-instar. The larva, or maggot, is the main feeding stage of the fly. On hatching, first-instar larvae are roughly 2 mm long, growing to about 5 mm before shedding their skin. Image: R. Major © Australian Museum

Stage 2: Initial decay – 0 to 3 days after death; Fly larvae – Maggots, First-instar

STAGES OF DECOMPOSITION | Stage 3: Putrefaction – 4 to 10 days after death

Decomposition Stage 3 Putrefaction 4 to 10 days after death

Stage 3: Putrefaction – 4 to 10 days after death

Stage 3: Putrefaction - 4 to 10 days after death Image: R. Major © Australian Museum

Stage 3: Putrefaction – 4 to 10 days after death

Stage 3: Putrefaction - 4 to 10 days after death Image: R. Major © Australian Museum

Stage 3: Putrefaction – 4 to 10 days after death


STAGES OF DECOMPOSITION | Stage 4: Black putrefaction – 10 to 20 days after death
Stage 4: Black putrefaction - 10 to 20 days after death Image: R. Major © Australian Museum

Stage 4: Black putrefaction – 10 to 20 days after death

Stage 4: Black putrefaction - 10 to 20 days after death Image: R. Major © Australian Museum

Stage 4: Black putrefaction – 10 to 20 days after death

Stage 4: Black putrefaction - 10 to 20 days after death Image: R. Major © Australian Museum

Stage 4: Black putrefaction – 10 to 20 days after death

I did not include the latter stages of decomposition as it seemed unlikely that a renderer would ever have to cope with corpses 20 days after its death.

QUESTIONS

To some consumers, it might simply be a matter of aesthetics, or it might be because of the perceived quality of the fats and proteins. To others, it may be more worrisome. It may be that rendered ingredients are made from diseased, inedible meat and poultry, and the odd horses. Or maybe they worry about pentobarbital or dioxins in rendered material. In which case, consumers may wish to avoid buying pet food with animal-fat, animal by-product, animal-digest, meat, and bone meal because those are likely to be from a renderer. 

The question consumers should ask themselves is: Is what you see on the pet food package or can differ from what you perceive rendered ingredients to be? Are the images on the packages and cans of pet food contradictory to the images of inedible meat and poultry – the witch’s brew of feet, heads, stomachs, intestines, hooves, spinal cords, tails, grease, feathers, and bones? Do you feel betrayed, or robbed of your choice because of misleading advertising claims?

I’d like to hear your thoughts.

SOURCES OF INFORMATION & HOW TO LEARN MORE

Stages of Decomposition, Museum of Natural History and Sciences Australia

Dar Pro Ingredients, a division of Darling Ingredients Inc., animal and pet food ingredients

Baker Commodities, Inc. protein meals, and feeding fats

Encyclopedia of Sh*t You Don’t Want to Know About, But Should: The Pet Food Industry Edition

A Rare Look Inside a Rendering Plant

Eating the Dead: Pet Food Only a Zombie Could Love; The Circular Madness of Upcycling Dead, Dying, and Diseased Animals into Food for Animals

Pet Food Industry’s Darkest Secret: Chemically Denatured Condemned and Inedible Material

dog cat poisoned pets safe food warnings news recalls alerts

Poisoned Pets | Pet Food Safety News remains free (and ad-free) and takes me hundreds of hours a month to research and write, and thousands of dollars a year to sustain. Even if all you can spare is $1 it will  help keep the website alive. If you find any value in what I do, please consider a donation of your choosing. Thank you!

PLEASE DONATE

 

 

Mollie Morrissette

Mollie Morrissette, the author of Poisoned Pets, is an animal food safety expert and consumer advisor. Help support her work by making a donation today.

Comments (8) Write a comment

  1. Thank you for your suggestions. I am beside myself with what to do. I’ve got a diabetic cat who won’t eat when I get “safe food.” I bought Science Diet Perfect Weight (against my better judgement) for my dog and he will not touch it. Back to the Internet I go to research more options. It’s so frustrating.

    Reply

    • Hi Kathy, I wrote to you privately to give you specific advice. To the rest of you here is what to Google: human-grade “human food facility” dehydrated pet food. Basically a product can only carry the official “human grade” label if it is made from human-grade ingredients AND processed in a human food facility. If the product contains human grade ingredients but is manufactured in a pet food facility, it loses the human grade distinction. And this a huge distinction.

      Reply

  2. Are their any reliable or valid sites online who can make recommendations for clean and healthy pet food? What I just read is nauseating; it turned my stomach. How can we protect our poor little fur babies? I can’t cook food at home for them.

    Reply

    • Kathy, I wish I could say there is a website that I could refer you too.

      Here is the problem: They all have one thing seriously wrong with them – they are biased because they have relationships with them – either financially or personally – therefore they cannot remain objective. Most of them sell the pet food (directly or indirectly) they “review.” Most have affiliate links to Amazon or Chewy. Most recommend pet food I would never recommend.

      Here is what I recommend: Buy a pet food that is not only made with human edible/grade ingredients but made in a human food facility as well – not a pet food plant. I do not recommend raw for this reason (read): Raw Pet Food: The Problem That Just Won’t Go Away

      I don’t ever recommend kibble, but I do like food made with dehydrated or fresh ingredients. I prefer that the food be heated to a temperature to 165F.

      I’m sorry, I just can’t say which company(s) I prefer, lest I be considered to be affiliated with them. But you’ll find them – they are out there.

      Reply

  3. It is getting to the point I really don’t know what to buy my dog for dog food. I was going with commercial raw I am in Ontario Canada but I thought is that safe? Now this, I drive by a farm on the way to work and at the very back of the farm in a back field near the road is a small container and every once in a while you see dead pigs in it sometimes one or sometimes many obviously died from some disease and they are put at the far end in this container it makes me sick wondering where are these poor pigs who died of something not normal heading…. in dog food?

    Reply

    • If you are concerned about rendered ingredients don’t buy pet food with animal by-products, meat and bone meal, animal fat, or animal digest in it.

      You should ask the farmer – who picks up their dead livestock? Chances are it is going to a renderer.

      That’s why they call it 4D meat: dead, dying, diseased and disabled animals. And those poor animals are the ones that – unfortunately – end up in pet food.

      Reply

  4. This is exactly why I have been cooking at home for all the dogs in my rescue for the last 20 years! It requires a lot of shopping, prepping and cooking to keep up with however many dogs I have with me but at least I know their food is safe.

    Reply

SHARE YOUR COMMENTS WITH US. YOUR OPINION MATTERS.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.